Two Attempts at Reviewing Postseason Performance

The tables below should hopefully give an idea of how often a QB does poorly in the postseason, and how his teams do when their QB plays below his standard.

First: "Bad game" defined as less than 6 adjusted yards per attempt. Last column is team W-L record in such games.



Kelly
59%
5-5
Marino
56%
1-9
McNabb
50%
2-6
Hasselbeck
45%
2-3
Roethlisberger
43%
3-3
P. Manning
42%
4-4
Elway
38%
4-4
Brady
36%
6-2
Young
36%
1-4
Rodgers
33%
1-1
Favre
29%
1-6
E. Manning
27%
0-3
Aikman
27%
1-3
Montana
26%
2-4
Warner
8%
1-0
Brees
0%
0-0


Second: "Bad game" defined as one where the QB's rating was lower than his career regular season rating. Last column is again the team W-L record in such games followed by W-L in the other games.



Kelly
71%
6-6
P. Manning
68%
5-8
Brady
68%
9-6
Marino
61%
2-9
Young
57%
3-5
Roethlisberger
57%
4-4
Favre
50%
2-10
Montana
48%
6-5
Warner
46%
3-3
Hasselbeck
45%
2-3
McNabb
44%
1-6
Elway
41%
4-5
Aikman
40%
2-4
Rodgers
33%
1-1
E. Manning
27%
1-2
Brees
22%
0-2